The Fifth Estate’s reporting on WE Charity was false. This website shows you what CBC did not: evidence, documents, and video that demonstrate CBC lied to its viewers.
CBC claimed that WE Charity deceived its donors, but the donors disagreed. WE Charity donors responsible for funding the vast majority of the projects in Kenya signed open letters rejecting the CBC’s false narrative about donor deception. Donors further stated they visited the projects they helped fund in Kenya and knew first-hand how their money was used.
CBC ignored the overwhelming evidence that its story was wrong and violated CBC’s own standards for investigative journalism. As this website shows, CBC knew that its reporting was wrong even before it aired.
WE Charity has filed a lawsuit in the United States, where the charity continues to operate. This lawsuit aims to set the record straight and hold CBC accountable.
Experts and people knowledgable on WE Charity share what happened and why.
CBC falsely claimed that WE Charity built only 360 schoolrooms in Kenya. They said the number “360” was WE Charity’s own count. From the outset of its reporting, CBC knew that WE Charity built far more than 360 schoolrooms in Kenya but lied about the figure because the real number contradicted their false story about missing schoolrooms.
The CBC falsely claimed that WE Charity “inflated” the number of schools it funded in Kenya by including latrines in its count of 852 schoolrooms. From the outset of its reporting, the CBC knew this allegation was false but lied because its entire donor deception story was premised on WE Charity’s full count of 852 schoolrooms being wrong.
The CBC falsely claimed that WE Charity was engaged in a cover-up to “block the scrutiny” by the CBC’s investigation. CBC's false claims of obstruction were essential to its preconceived narrative because it gave them an excuse not to visit or verify the 852 schools and schoolrooms WE Charity funded.
The reporters behind this coverage have a history of misrepresenting facts and publishing preconceived narratives regardless of the facts and the evidence.
Alberta pathologist lawsuit vs. CBC
KPMG lawsuit vs. CBC
WE Charity lawsuit vs. CBC
“Now, a months-long Fifth Estate investigation into WE Charity's Kenyan operations reveals that far fewer schools were built than were funded by donors..”“Such activities were common practice and part of a multi-faceted strategy that brought in funding for more than 900 primary schoolhouses in Kenya, where WE Charity records show only 360 have actually been built since its work began in 2003.”What do the sources show?WE Charity provided CBC and the public photos of every schoolroom it funded in Kenya, 852 of them.
WE Charity provided CBC and the public maps of where every schoolroom in Kenya is located
CBC claimed that in response to its reporting, WE Charity hired a forensic auditor who determined, in the words of CBC, "that all donations to Kenya between April 1, 2012, and August 31, 2020, total $74 million. At the same time, costs for projects in Kenya were $54.8 million, while costs for WE Canada, including administration, were $29 million. The total costs were ‘$83.8 million or $9.8 million more’ than donations designated for Kenya."
CBC intentionally claimed that $29 million dollars was diverted to Canada when the report by their own go-to forensic auditor stated the opposite.
WE Charity hired the CBC’s own go-to forensic auditor to independently confirm whether all of the funds raised for Kenya went to Kenya. They did. Additionally, the CBC intentionally withheld a phrase within the forensic audit report which clearly stated the $29 million referenced in the report was paid directly to vendors in Kenya or for things such as medical supplies which were purchased in North America and sent to Kenya.
WE Charity hired the CBC’s own go-to forensic auditor to independently confirm whether all of the funds raised for Kenya went to Kenya. They did. Additionally, the CBC intentionally withheld a phrase within the forensic audit report which clearly stated the $29 million referenced in the report was paid directly to vendors in Kenya or for things such as medical supplies which were purchased in North America and sent to Kenya.
The Kenyan government confirmed that CBC never received permission to visit government-run schools.
The reports to donor Watson Jordan do not say “here is the school built in memory of your son” as claimed by the CBC.
CBC falsely claimed the schoolroom number included latrines and removed an interviewee’s statement that WE Charity’s count did not include latrines and instead added a voiceover saying the opposite.
“WE Charity, then known as Free the Children, had collected donations to build two schools. Instead, they built one and told both donors they had paid for it.“
“The deception resulted in multiple donor groups paying for the same schoolhouses many times over.“
Donors, who funded the vast majority of the projects in Kenya, wrote CBC and told it they were wrong. Educators whose schools supported projects in Kenya wrote CBC and told it they were wrong.
CBC did not show a single example of the social media postings they claimed said that donors fully funded over 900 schools.
CBC did not show the whole document where WE Charity supposedly said it only built 360 schoolrooms.
CBC did not show a single example of a latrine being counted as a schoolroom.
CBC did not show the WE Charity email that supposedly told a donor he fully funded a specific schoolroom.
CBC did not show the leaked WE Charity documents it claimed to quote.
CBC told donors they were deceived. In one interview the person being interviewed said “If what you’re saying is true, that’s really disappointing.”
CBC did not show any permission it received to visit the government-run schools where it filmed in claiming that the Kenyan government’s accusations of trespassing were “un-founded”.
CBC did not show how it counted schools when it claimed they were not there.
CBC did not show how WE Charity described and marketed what it would do with donor money.
From harassing charity donors and pressuring them to agree to invented story lines, the unethical journalism practiced by CBC is fully documented in What WE Lost. Readers are shown just how low CBC sunk in trying to drive a completely invented narrative.
Martin Luther King III reads from What WE Lost to share how CBC producers pressured past WE Charity donors to follow a narrative he created and speak against WE Charity on camera.
Listen to Chapter 16 free on Spotify | Apple
There was a measure of trust on the part of the Kielburgers—after all, the CBC is a public broadcaster, financed largely by taxpayer dollars, and it touts its commitment to journalistic principles of accuracy, balance, and fairness. The brothers understood there would be tough questions, but they were told by the CBC that this would also be an opportunity to remind viewers of all the good the organization had done and to put a period at the end of the sentence as it wound down its Canadian operations.
Most concerning to me was how little Kelley and his team—including Fifth Estate producer Harvey Cashore—understood about the cultures and communities in which WE Charity operated and the work the organization did on the ground. For instance, Kelley brought up the supposedly fake kitchen that Bloomberg reporter Natalie Obiko Pearson had asked about in her emails and later described in her lengthy article.
He was told there was no truth to that rumour, but Harvey Cashore raised it again in a conversation with Marc and Craig in early January. This time, he was shown a picture of a substantial kitchen built of chiselled stone, with a cement floor and piped clean water—proof that nothing had been slapped together to fool a donor—but he continued to protest. If it was a kitchen, he asked, why was there no refrigerator? The organization had to explain that rural Kenyans do not typically have refrigerators because homes often do not have electricity.
Many people would have felt embarrassed about making such an error, but apparently Cashore did not. The CBC went ahead and alleged in its February documentary that the charity “manufactured” a kitchen overnight to deceive a donor.